Read CAI's Blog!







The National Law Journal Selects CAI's Amicus Curiae Brief in Camreta v. Greene / Alford v. Greene as "Brief of the Week"



On February 23, 2011, The National Law Journal selected the Children's Advocacy Institute's Amicus Curiae brief to the U.S. Supreme Court in Camreta v. Greene / Alford v. Greene as the "Brief of the Week."

These cases, which will be the subject of oral argument before the Court on March 1, 2011, involve a Ninth Circuit holding that requires parental consent, or a warrant (or similar court detention probable cause order) under Fourth Amendment standards, before Child Protective Services social workers can conduct an in-school interview of a suspected child abuse victim.

In its brief, which was submitted in support of neither party, CAI argues that the Ninth Circuit's ruling imposes a serious barrier that will impede and in some cases cut off child abuse investigations. Requiring parental consent is problematic because parents are involved in 80% of child abuse cases. The alternative obstacle of a probable-cause based warrant or detention order is complicated by both the time and resources required for its acquisition, and the fact that probable cause achievement typically comes from the child interview (not before it occurs), which creates a “Catch-22” preclusion to effective CPS inquiry.

CAI Executive Director Robert Fellmeth explains CAI's position:

"We have all sorts of checks and balances in the system when someone has taken a child without basis from the home or where the state has intervened inappropriately or excessively. But if a CPS worker does not remove a child who is being raped or tortured every night, there is no safeguard....I'm not saying you should be able to interview for any reason. I want reasonable suspicion. I just know what probable cause means. I know the difference between the two, and that's the line you don't want to cross when protecting a victim and you're only game in town."

To view CAI's brief in full, please click here.



© 2017 CAI
All rights reserved
Children's Advocacy Institute
University of San Diego School of Law
5998 Alcalá Park, San Diego, CA 92110
Telephone: 619.260.4806
Fax: 619.260.4753